Topper Copies

Critically examine the 'in-house procedure' adopted by the Apex Court to inquire into allegations of misconduct against judges of constitutional courts in India.

A R Rajah Mohaideen, AIR 7, 2025

The recent case of money embezzlement of current Varanasi[?] Justice Verma has brought to light 'protectionism' within Judiciary.

Limitations of this procedure 1. Uncle Judge Syndrome and nepotism / favouritism will reduce the penalising hand. 2. Protectionism and immunibility[?] of Judiciary goes against the 'Doctrine of checks and Balances'. 3. Lack of Accountability on part of judiciary to the citizens. 4. Lack of transparency in procedure leads to arbitrary judgements. 5. Goes against impeachment procedure given by the Constitution against the judges.

Positives 1. Faster and efficient disposal. 2. Prevention of occurence of frivolous cases. 3. Helps in bringing of expert opinion -> given by judges. 4. Prevents the media trial and undermining of Judicial Privacy.

Way Forward 1. A combined body of legislature and judiciary to be constituted for enquiry. 2. Constitutional ammendment to the impeadment process to include the combined enquiry process. 3. Taking help of bodies like CBI and ED in collecting proof of misconduct. 4. Constant availability of information to the public regarding the enquiry.

Thus, judiciary should not overreach and undermine its 'legislative brother', going against Separation of Powers,