'The recommendations of the 15th Finance Commission have enabled the States to improve their fiscal conditions.' Comment.
A R Rajah Mohaideen, AIR 7, 2025
The Finance Commission derives its power from Article 280, showing how it acts as the enabler of fiscal democracy and federalism.
Recommendations 1. Vertical Devolution - Recommendation of 41% of funds devolution from centre 2. Horizontal Devolution - Based on criteria like forest cover, tax reforms, population, demographic performance, funds are divided to different states
Enablers of Improvement 1. Ensures the timely delivery of funds needed for development. 2. States of North have greater chunk of tax funds to improve their fiscal conditions. 3. Overseeing of Art. 292 and Art. 293 has also helped in easing out borrowing norms. 4. Statutory & Discretionary grants (Art. 278 and 282) have been timely dealt with.
However, certain lacunae do exist 1. Southern states have complained of contributing more but receiving less. - Eg: T.N. Finance Minister's comment 2. Similarly, there is dire need of changing the criteria. 3. States should be given better incentive for tax reforms.
[a map of India labelled "Every 1Re. by U.P. gets back Rs 2.5" and "Every 1 Rs. contributed by T.N., gets back 20 paise", captioned "Fig:- Discrepancy"]
Thus, fiscal federalism would go a long way in 'holding together' our Union.