Topper Copies

The evolution of property rights in India reflects an intricate relationship that exists between individual rights and public welfare. Discuss this statement with the help of relevant constitutional provisions and case laws.

A R Rajah Mohaideen, AIR 7, 2025

The journey of Indian democracy has always been a tussle between balancing individual rights and public welfare, seen between fundamental rights and DPSPs.

Evolution of Property Rights 1. Initially, Right to Property was a fundamental right under Part-III of the constitution. 2. this implied the ability to use Article 32 to bring upon writs to enforce this right. 3. This, however goes against the DPSP Article 39 where the state has to strive for equitable distribution of wealth. 4. This made them to pass the Constitutional Ammendment Act (24th) which removed Right to Property to Article 300 as a constitutional right. 5. When challenged in the Keshavananda Bharati case of (1973) the Parliamentary sovereignity to uphold constitutional ammendments was upheld. 6. Thus, in the debate of property rights, social welfare takes precedence over individual rights. - Eg: 42nd CAA - added 'Socialist' to preamble. 7. However, due protection to property have been listed out in Article 34.

Thus, as the former Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud commented, the judiciary should help entangle the relationships between rights and welfare.