Topper Copies

The ordinance-making power of the executive is antithetical to the principles of accountability and democratic consensus. Examine with suitable illustrations.

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

Article 123 provides president with the ordinance making power during the recess of parliament.

Ordinance : Antithetical to accountability & democratic consensus 1. Bypass legislative scrutiny. - eg National Capital territory Civil services board ordinance, 2023 2. Misused to pass unpopular laws. 3. Provides a way do avoid accountability 4. Subsequent repromulgation violates spirit of Constitution ( D.C. Wadhwa Case) 5. Limits the participation of opposition. 6. Violates seperation of power between executive & legislature.

Need for Ordinance (accepted as Constitutional in R.C Cooper Case) 1. Counter Sudden challenges - eg financial resource requirements 2. Counter emerging threats 3. Resolve legislative deadlocks 4. filling legal vaccum.

Thus although necessary, the usages should be avoided to bypass Legislative scrutiny & president should excercise utmost constraint