Lateral entry into civil services is seen as a reformative step, yet it continues to attract criticism and controversy. Discuss.
A R Rajah Mohaideen, AIR 7, 2025
Lateral entry means the appointment of Civil Servants at the secretarial level, ensuring domain expertise and efficiency.
I. Reformative Step 1. Brings in specialists to improve efficiency. - Eg: Parameshwaran IAS brought into spearhead the Swachh Bharat mission. 2. Helps in curbing red tapism. 3. Will ensure civil servants do mid-career training to keep themselves competitive. - => Hota Committee Recommendation 4. Helps in breaking the criminal, political, executive nexus, by bringing in experts. - => Vohra Committee recommendation.
II. Criticism and Controversy 1. Incumbent Officers 1. Passed over by lateral entry officers for promotion. 2. Undermines their seniority and grade pay scale. 3. Undermines the efforts put into service by them. 2. Political 1. Lateral entry is used for political favourable postings. 2. No particular criteria for selection -> accentuates this problem. 3. Lateral entry officers 1. May lack knowledge of governance. 2. Domain knowledge need not translate to public administration.
Measures 1. Proper framework for selection. 2. Should be done in a phased manner. 3. Performance based salary for the new joinee.
Thus, the steel frame has to be galvanised with lateral entry.