Is the growing demand for stricter regulation of online content justified, or does it pose a threat to the right to freedom of speech and expression? Examine in light of recent judicial pronouncements.
A R Rajah Mohaideen, AIR 7, 2025
The recent judgment in the Ranveer Allahabadia case has highlighted the issue of 'level' of control of online content.
Justification for stricter regulation 1. Prevents the invasion of pornography - Eg: POCSO Act highlights children as prey for pornography. 2. Helps in bringing out press and television censor (Broadcast Regulation Rules) to Online. - Eg: IT Rules - censorship of online content. 3. Justified in taking out radicalising content. - Eg: Model of Online radicalisation used in Jammu and Kashmir. 4. Justified in reducing misinformation. - Eg: PIB Fact check on twitter flagging hundreds of fake tweets.
Threat to freedom of speech and expression 1. Judiciary cautioned with the Doctrine of Proportionality - Eg: Shreya Shingal Case of access to internet services. 2. Another judgement curbed the excessant IT rules censorship. - Eg: Kunal Kamra Case against IT rules. 3. The extension of Art. 21 has also led to increasing the access to internet. - => Maneka Gandhi Case - Due process of law. 4. Thus, the court has highlighted that proportionality has to come into play for curbing online content.
Way Forward 1. Reducing restrictions on dissenting voices. 2. Not using legislations as weapons against opposition. 3. Penalising effectively - vulgar and crude content.
Thus, as the former Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud commented, caution has to be taken in any case of censorship.