Topper Copies

The constitution of India is not a 'bag of borrowing, but a 'beautiful patchwork' that aptly mirrors the nation's diversity. Comment.

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

Critics often criticised Indian Constitution as a bag of borrowings as it extensively borrowed provisions from various sources.

Constitution: A bag of borrowing 1. UK -> Parliamentary form of government (Art. 74,75) - Legislative procedure. 2. USA -> preamble, fundamental rights (Part III) - Judicial independence. 3. Ireland -> DPSP (Part IV), President Election. 4. South Africa -> Joint sitting - Election of Rajya Sabha MP. 5. USSR -> fundamental duties, Concept of Justice 6. France -> Liberty, Equality, fraternity (Preamble)

Constitution as a beautiful patchwork mirroring diversity 1. Parliamentary system due to diverse population & their interest. - responsibility over stability 2. fundamental rights preserve minority rights. (Art. 29, 30) 3. Rajya Sabha to strengthen federalism 4. Eighth schedule recognise Linguistic diversity (22 Languages) 5. 5th & 6th Schedule to preserve diverse tribal culture.

Thus, it is rightly pointed that the Indian Constitution is the manifestation of diverse interest & demands of the Indian nation.