Topper Copies

"Parliamentary committees serve as the engine room of legislative scrutiny, delving deep into policy matters and holding the government to account." In this perspective, evaluate the role of departmentally-related standing committees in holding the executive accountable to the parliament.

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

Parliamentary Committee are those which are elected by the house, nominated by speaker/Chairman, present reports to the house or has a Secretarial provided by lok Sabha/Rajya Sabha.

Parliamentary Committee: Engine room of scrutiny (role of departmental committees) - a) Deeper & clause by clause discussion of provisions. - b) Keeping the government accountable - c) Provide a stage for opposition to raise concerns - d) Allow experts to put their opinions over provisions - e) Scrutinise the demand for grants & the usage of funds. - f) Allow deeper discussion without politicisation of issues. - g) Promote expertise among members

However, they are facing issues - a) Reduction in number of bills presented before committees

[a line graph, bills to committees across the 15th, 16th and 17th Lok Sabha, falling from 55% to 18%]

- b) Short tenure of only 1 year. - c) Absenteeism among members - eg 50% average attendance - d) Members following party lines due to fear of anti defection law. - e) Irregular discussion of reports by the house. - f) Dominance of single party at the Centre

Thus following reforms as suggested by National Commission for review of Working of constitution are required.

Suggested reform - a) Extending the tenure to atleast two years - b) Mandating minimum attendance for members - c) Regular discussion over reports. - d) Integrate civil society, private sector into the process. - e) Live streaming of the committee proceedings. - f) Provisions for larger role of Opposition in committees - g) Mandate compulsory discussion in Committees over certain bills.

Hence, the Committees can increase the eficacy of parliament through proper scrutiny.