"Parliamentary committees serve as the engine room of legislative scrutiny, delving deep into policy matters and holding the government to account." In this perspective, evaluate the role of departmentally-related standing committees in holding the executive accountable to the parliament.
Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025
Parliamentary Committee are those which are elected by the house, nominated by speaker/Chairman, present reports to the house or has a Secretarial provided by lok Sabha/Rajya Sabha.
Parliamentary Committee: Engine room of scrutiny (role of departmental committees) - a) Deeper & clause by clause discussion of provisions. - b) Keeping the government accountable - c) Provide a stage for opposition to raise concerns - d) Allow experts to put their opinions over provisions - e) Scrutinise the demand for grants & the usage of funds. - f) Allow deeper discussion without politicisation of issues. - g) Promote expertise among members
However, they are facing issues - a) Reduction in number of bills presented before committees
[a line graph, bills to committees across the 15th, 16th and 17th Lok Sabha, falling from 55% to 18%]
- b) Short tenure of only 1 year. - c) Absenteeism among members - eg 50% average attendance - d) Members following party lines due to fear of anti defection law. - e) Irregular discussion of reports by the house. - f) Dominance of single party at the Centre
Thus following reforms as suggested by National Commission for review of Working of constitution are required.
Suggested reform - a) Extending the tenure to atleast two years - b) Mandating minimum attendance for members - c) Regular discussion over reports. - d) Integrate civil society, private sector into the process. - e) Live streaming of the committee proceedings. - f) Provisions for larger role of Opposition in committees - g) Mandate compulsory discussion in Committees over certain bills.
Hence, the Committees can increase the eficacy of parliament through proper scrutiny.