Topper Copies

"The true function of a legislature is to discuss and deliberate and not merely to pass laws." Do you think the deliberative role of parliament has deteriorated over time? If so, what factors have contributed to this decline? Suggest measures to make the parliament a more effective forum for policy deliberations.

Harsh Nehara, AIR 74, 2025

Article 79 provides for a parliament to discuss & debate crucial policy matters of the nation.

[a line graph, bills presented to committees, falling from 55% to 15% across the 16th, 17th and 18th]

factors behind such deterioration - a) Poor opposition with weak mandate. eg No leader of opposition in 17th lok Sabha - b) Unresponsive nature of government during question hours - - c) Anti-defection law curtailing freedom of legislators eg "People men" to "party men" - d) Increased usage of money bill route eg Aadhar act, 2016 - e) Poor quality of research by Legislators & lack of expert support - f) Criminalisation of politics & emergence of nexuses eg 46% MP with C Criminal cases

However, there are still discussions - a) Increased mandate for opposition in 2024 General elections - b) Detailed scrutiny of budget by Committees - c) Question by independent & nominated members - eg Sudha Murty on usage of pesticides.

Measures required for effective policy deliberations - a) Providing expert support to legislators. - b) fixing the minimum amount of sitting hours (law commission report) - c) Redefine defection to promote independent thinking among MP's (Goswami committee) - d) Live streaming of all parliamentary proceedings - e) UK practice : opposition decide business of house for 20 days. - f) Tackling criminalisation through fast track courts & public awareness.

Hence, to transform parliament into a town square for national discussion, structural reforms are required.