Topper Copies

Do you think NATO as a system of US-led collective security for Europe is relevant in an increasingly multipolar world? Justify your answer.

Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025

North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, a creature of Cold war era, has become key to fist-fighting in the Ukrainian theatre of war - thus being hurled into relevance.

A Relevant Cog in Polycentric crises

1. NATO involvement as a 'front' to Russia-China proxy wars - eg Ukraine - eg Korea - eg Central Asia - eg East Europe - Serbia - Kosovo conflict

[a sketch map of Eurasia labelled Russia, Ukraine, CAR, China, Korea, East Europe] 2. Increased involvement in defence aid to Ukraine and Israel 3. Deterrence factor against raising belligerents in various theatres of conflict 4. Collective funnel for aid and assistance 5. checking expansionist tendencies of Russia, China 6. Bringing together multidimensional cooperation beyond defence - eg B3W initiative 7. increased membership eg Finland

However; its relevance on other accounts has been negatively challenged:

1. Structure of cold war, non-inductment of contemporary realities - facilitates US's worldview of hegemonic dominance and its interests as supreme. 2. Primacy to 'Europe's problems as world's problems' - EAM Jaishankar. 3. Increased militarization over dialogue 4. Divergences among members - eg Trump divergences on pulling out and financial cut back 5. Rise of Russia's CSTO and multipolar balancers like India on rise. 6. 'Minilateralism' - QUAD

Thus, while NATO pushes itself into relevance via conflictual attention, it has now been limited in its relevance to 'European contingencies' as opposed to 'global contingencies' of Cold war