Topper Copies

Throwing light on the constitutional provisions for safeguarding the autonomy of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG,) recommend measures to enhance its role as the conscience keeper of the government.

Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025

CAG (Art 148) is the beholder of financial scrutiny and legitimacy on democratic edifice of execution accountability.

6. Appointment committee balanced to create autonomous and bias-free appointment

This substantiates CAG's role as 'conscience keeper' via: 1. Audits - propriety audit - performance audit - financial audit/appropriation audit 2. Principle of 3 Es via audits - effectiveness - efficiency - expenditure resilience. 3. Philosopher, guide, friend of Public Accounts committee.

Apart from above, measures are needed to safeguard its role since Impediments to its working exist:

1. Not all paragraphs recommend to PAC discussed - eg 15-20 paras out of 1500-2000 discussed, on average 2. CAG is not mainstreamed - need to increase exposure for citizen awareness to further public accountability 3. Post facto audit 4. No control over expenditures 5. Merely recommendatory effect

Thus, reforms for transformative role are sine qua non:

1. Addition of 'comptroller role' like in UK 2. Not post facto, but real time audit of expenditures 3. Scrutiny of demand-for-grants before budgetary approval 4. Increased integration of PAC and CAG for effective parliamentary control. 5. Not just recommendatory, but binding effect of CAG 6. Implementing a 'foundation' for 'propriety audit' to check for effectiveness of schemes - eg NSAP, for mass[?] advertisement scam 7. Diversified ambit. - eg Tea Board and illegal blending in Darjeeling tea.

Thus, CAG as the conscience keeper remains 'centre stage of financial probity' as per SK Basu-