While the Emergency of 1975 was touted as seminal for national security and unity by some, the critics paint it as the darkest phase of Post Independent India. Discuss. What insights and lessons did emergency provide for the country?
Farkhanda Qureshi, AIR 67, 2024
Emergency of 1975 was considered as a dark chapter of Indian history post Independence. It was declared on the basis of "internal disturbance" under Article 352 of constitution of India.
Seminal for national security
Dark phase in history of post independent India:-
1. Curtailing of freedom of speech and expression (Article 19): 2. opposition leaders were jailed & kept in house arrest 3. Change made in Constitution's basic structure through 42nd Amendment Act termed as "Mini constitution" 4. Forced sterilisation carried in public camps to control population explosion - but this backfire. 5. Elections postponed & right to vote not practicaed by people. 6. Delusional feature of executive towards the judiciary. - eg:- appointment of judge made based on Executive whims & fancies.
Insights & lessons provided by Emergency:-
1. Despotic rule is not the true nature of Indian democracy. - as the govt. was overthrown in next general elections. 2. Undo of the changes made in Constitution by 44th Amendment Act - eg:- "internal disturbance" replaced by armed rebellion. 3. Emergency lessons learnt & never implemented since them. 4. Committee of interrogation was setup to look into the exigencies of time & space. - Shah committee considered the emergency as unlawful. 5. Punchhi committee recommended for localised emergency. 6. Time limit for approval of emergency reduced to 1 month from 2 month earlier.
Emergency must thus be seen as a "last resort".