The 69th constitutional amendment provides special provisions for the Union Territory of Delhi. Discuss and analyse the implications of divergences on various issues between the elected government and the Lieutenant Governor.
Ria Kaur Sethi, AIR 89, 2024
69th constitutional Ammendment act provided the status of National Capital territory to the union territory of Delhi.
Special Provisions of 69 CAA
1. 70 member state legislative assembly called Vidhan Sabha. 2. Vidhan Sabha to make laws on all subjects except law & order, land & police. 3. These 3 subjects lie in the domain of the Lieutenant Governor 4. Council of Ministers to not exceed 10% of the strength of the state legislature assembley. 5. In case of dispute between CM and LG -> matter to be refered to the President
Implications of divergences between the LG & CM
1. Very slow pace of decision making - The home delivery of services bill was not passed by the LG for months. 2. Blame game in which the citizen suffers - Eg Recent coaching case flooding tragedy became a blame game rather instead of setting accountability. 3. Increasing burden on Supreme court - Repeated cases sent to the SC, add to its already pending share of cases - "Justice delayed is denied" 4. Led to a tussle between Lok Sabha & Judiciary - Judiciary said reference to President should not be for every bill. - Also, civil servants under control of delhi legislature - - However, LS act overturned this
Hence, this tussle is not healthy or exemplary for federalism & a sustainable solution for the same needs to be sought using UK Model & Germany Model.