Topper Copies

Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the first-past-the-post (FPTP) system in ensuring representative polity. Can a move to proportional electoral system address the limitations of the first-past-the-post system?

Ria Kaur Sethi, AIR 89, 2024

First Past the post system refers to declaring a winner of a constituency in an election, based on who gets the maximum votes. - Eg Party A getting 31 votes, as compared to 30 votes of Party B => Party A is FPTP and wins.

Strengths of First Past the Post

1. Easier to understand for common populace - 100 cr voters and 75% literacy 2. continuity from Pre Independence era - hence ease of transition 3. Uses limited resources as only 1 round is conducted - as opposed to proportional rep. through single transferable vote used for President -> multiple rounds

Weaknesses of FPTP system.

1. Not representative of the constituency. - Eg Party A got only 31% vote share and won, but doesn't represent 70% of the constituency. 2. encourages polarisation of voters - often tactics like hate speech is resorted to, so that the vote is split and majority gained 3. Parties go to any extent in terms of funding to get first past the post - with 1.37 lakh crore expenditure, 18th LS elections were most expensive in world

PROPORTIONAL SYSTEM AS REMEDY

1. Proportional system refers to allocating seats to each party, in proportion of votes received / total votes. 2. It will help adress problem of representativeness -> as all political parties get representation a/c to vote share 3. Polarisation as a strategy fails, as total votes proceed all taken into a/c.

However, the National committee to review the working of the Constitution said a mixture of both FPTP and proportional can be experimented with