Topper Copies

The ordinance-making power of the executive is antithetical to the principles of accountability and democratic consensus. Examine with suitable illustrations.

Ria Kaur Sethi, AIR 89, 2024

Ordinance making power has been granted to the President on advice of Prime Minister & council of Ministers under Article 123.

Antithetical to accountability

1. As President and PM along with CoM are not answerable to the legislature for ordinances. 2. Legislatures represent the will of the people, & bypassing them compromises accountability - Eg [?] sent by cabinet later had to be overturned

Affects democratic consensus

1. without consensus & debate in LS & RS -> principle of democracy is compromised 2. Views of states, minorities & can be steam rolled using the ordinance route. - Eg death penalty for gang rapes came as an ordinance -> needed public debate.

Way Forward

- DC Cooper & case prevents repromulgation of ordinance without passing through legislature. - RC Wadhwa recommends ordinances in rarest of rare case

Hence, ordinance making power should be used strictly in emergencies to safeguard accountability & democracy