The Indian constitution is unique in the sense that it not only creates a limited government but also establishes a welfare state. Explain with suitable examples.
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
Indian Constitution is a document for a millenia - addresses the social, political, economic democracy to the roots and top of the canopy alike.
Limited Govt
In eliminating 'tyranny of executive', it benchmarks itself in following way:
1. adoption of 'constitutional supremacy' model -> an able mix and play of separation of power doctrine 2. Part III - Fundamental Rights as a stamp on containment. - eg Art 14, 15 - Equality Before Law - Reasonable nexus for classification by executive 3. Rights available against state - eg right against untouchability. - eg secularism - AA 25-28 - eg Disabling state from handholding any one religion and progress of all -> Article 29 - minority rights 4. Article 13 - (a) defined jurisdiction/competency of executive. - (b) Antithetical/contravening Laws, rules, decrees, regulations declared void by judiciary. 5. Prerogative writs (AA 32, 226) available against state tyranny and excesses - eg habeas corpus for illegal detention 6. Judiciary - Art 142 -> 'complete justice' to check executive excesses like delegated legislation. 7. Parliamentary control - budgetary - Committee on Subordinate Legislat[ion]
Additionally, it balances the above with a socialistic state oriented towards welfarism via a hue of provisions:
1. Directive principles - fundamental to governance, establish a 'welfare state' (Article 37) - (A) eg AA 38 -> against inequality of opportunity and status (Preamble) - (B) AA 39 -> enabling provisions for livelihood, & concentration of wealth and common good. - (C) Art 40 - grassroots welfare via Panchayati Raj governance (Gandhi's Antyodaya & Sarvodaya) - (D) Art 48A welfare via environmental resilience. 2. Article 21 - Provision of 'meaningful life' (Maneka Gandhi case, substantiated by human dignity and 'personal liberty') -> positive rights jurisprudence enabled by AA 21 - Right to healthy environment (Subhash Kumar case) - Right to shelter - Right to livelihood (AA 41, Olga Tellis case)
Thus, the constitution harmoniously teams a limited yet welfare-based powered government.