Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the first-past-the-post (FPTP) system in ensuring a representative polity. Can a move towards a proportional electoral system address the limitations of the first-past-the-post system?
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
First-Past-the-Post system was adopted by Constituent Assembly in line with representative polity aspirations to espin[?] it truly 'fair' elections., but was a highly contested decision.
FPTP: boon/bane?
Strengths -> impact
1. provides eased representation -> Reconcilable differences 2. Stable government formed - ability to secure majority -> Robust & Easy policy making 3. Political parties interface in 'territorial constituency' -> touchbase with voters and thus, public accountability ensured. 4. Access to representative - territorially responsible -> Grievance redressal and customized law-making
However, the FPTP was criticized on various accounts in the Constituent Assembly - labelled as 'majoritarian tool':
Proposals for proportional representation system, as used in Presidential elections, were propounded.
Advantages
1. Addresses large diversity -> voice to all sections 2. Proportional and equitable governance 3. Inclusive growth orientation
Disadvantages
1. Not suitable for elephantine size of Indian population 2. TOO much diversity renders it Ineffective -> no party with majority - 'hung Parl. syndrome' 3. Very expensive on fiscal exchequer 4. Inability to conduct byelections. 5. TOO complex for all voters to comprehend.
Thus, while it has its demerits, The FPTP system has been ably administered by ECI and has rightfully called India as a representative, participative and consultative democracy.