The ordinance-making power of the executive is antithetical to the principles of accountability and democratic consensus. Examine with suitable illustrations.
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
Ordinance making powers, borrowed from earlier dispensation, are encapsulated in Article 123 and 231, vested with the President and Governor respectively.
Antithetical to consensus
- Lack of representative honing - 'Closed door legislature' syndrome - Eased abridgement / overpowering legislature eg Land acquisition Ordinance - diminished executive accountability with supreme power to legislate at own whims - continuous renewal of ordinance post 6 months expiry - eg Bihar Governor pulled up earlier for continuous renewal. - Incessant tool for tyranny of executive, furthering blurring of separation of powers - undermining Parliamentary form in absence of consensus of people of Parliament.
However, whilst a dig on accountability and consensus based democratic legislating, it is critical to effective functioning:
1. Quick response to contingencies 2. Coalition politics confronts challenges of inability to take strong decisions. 3. Long drawn parliamentary procedures delay implementation - eg Covid: Essential Commodity Act ordinance 4. Policy-making eased due to on completion in time.
Thus, whilst critical problems and aberration have been observed, the significance in retaining remains due to - quick dispensation - constitutional check of expiry - Judicial check of review - Lack of jurisdiction to amend constitution.