Topper Copies

The cooperative nature of Indian federalism is being increasingly challenged by emerging differences in Centre-State relations. Discuss. What steps can be taken to strengthen the cooperative spirit of Indian federalism?

Ria Kaur Sethi, AIR 89, 2024

Federalism is a basic feature of the Indian constitution as declared by the SR Bommai case. DD Basu, calls India's federalism sui generis

Challenges arising in India's federal structure

1. Funding tussles - states like Tamil Nadu demanding more share of taxes as it gives Rs 1, but get Rs 0.29 p from central pool 2. Issues with GST compensation - [?] states suffer wrath of 2.67 cr of GST compensation was not being paid to them. 3. Political tussles - Recently West Bengal government refused to share the water of Teesta with Bangladesh - M. Singh -> "compulsions of coalition" 4. Fight over Capital - Recent 'NCT Delhi Ammendment Bill' gives disproportionate power to LG & also overrules the judgement of the SC. 5. Regional disparity & demand for special category status - 3 x 3 x 3 trouble - 3 largest state have 3x revenue than smallest states

Way Forward for federalism

1. Cooperative model of Federalism show by NITI aayog through vertical integration Eg Team India 2. Use of Inter state council, u/A 263 to resolve disputes 3. SC asked both parties to follow constitutional morality & not lionise themselves. 4. Innovative models like 'pooled sovereignity' of GST council 5. Best practices & Technical support to be shared by centre to augment development. Eg Aspirational districts to Blocks.

Our unique model of Federalism keeps 28 states, 8 UTs and 22 scheduled languages tied as a strong & unified unit.