The constitution of India is not a bag of borrowing, but a 'beautiful patchwork' that aptly mirrors the nation's diversity. Comment.
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
Every nation-state, sui generis in its history, geography and polity, presents a variegated picture of socio-economic landscape - with extraneous impacts abound - in this case, the constitutional borrowings by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar and founding fathers.
A Bag of Borrowings?
- British Constitution - Parliamentary form of govt. - Prerogative writs (AA 32, 226) - Westminster model of governance - bicameralism - Lower house -> House of Commons - Upper House -> House of Lord - US constitution - Bill of Rights - Fundamental Rights (Part III) - Vice President - Impeachment procedure. - Canadian Constitution -> Quasi-federal model of polity - Australian - Concurrent list - Taxation - trade & commerce regulations. - Irish constitution -> Directive principles of State policy (Part IV)
However, even with a 'large hue of borrowings', the Constitution remains 'Indian to its core' - a 'beautiful patchwork' canvassing:
1. Localized in its tenor to customize to Indian contextuality - eg Secularism - principled distance (Art 25-28) 2. Best practices already explored by the best of Constitutions - more apt to borrow from the experienced, per Ambedkar. 3. Although caricatured as 'a guitar when we wanted a veena' (Hanumanthaiya), remains, largely, an Indian document -> GoI Act 1935 was in fact an Indian legal document.
Thus, whilst a 'guitar' on first look, the constitution remains a 'mirror' to the diversities and represents Indian aspirations in the