Topper Copies

Recently, the Supreme Court has expanded the scope of Articles 14 and 21 to include the "right against adverse effects of climate change". In this context, citing relevant case laws, discuss the role played by Indian judiciary in 'constitutionalization' of environmental issues.

Ria Kaur Sethi, AIR 89, 2024

Recently, Supreme court expanded the scope of Article 21 by including 'right to be safeguarded from adverse effects of climate change'.

Constitutionalisation of environmental issues

1. MC Mehta case - lays down a balance between environmental conservation and developmental activities. - It also asks to form a commission to address the same. 2. Right against noise pollution - by specifying that the edge of a public place can only have <30 Db above ambient noise level. 3. Outlawing firecrackers & putting time limits on their use during Diwali in Delhi. 4. Niyamgiri case - SC stopped Vedanta from mining & preserved rights of Dongria Kondhs + environment.

Significance of these laws

1. Judicial acceptance of worsening climate change - Great Indian Bustard case -> SC asked to lay lines underground. 2. Will also create domino effect for change in other spheres.

Article 21 is the most expansively interpreted Fundamental right starting with 'Due Process of Law' in Maneka Gandhi case.