Topper Copies

Wealthy CEOs and founders of successful businesses around the world are increasingly pledging to give away their wealth in philanthropy. Do you think that such a move is sufficient enough to bring about a positive change in the society? Critically examine.

Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023

Altruism and Gandhian trusteeship exhort us to give away extra wealth for equity.

This is very well needed 1. Currently we have high level of inequality - Gini coefficient of 0.35 in India. 2. Bring positive change towards value of minimalism (Buddha) 3. Life of satisfaction as uphold higher order needs (Maslow) 4. Reduce lack of money among lower strata ⇒ better mental health ⊕ life of dignity (Article 21)

However just giving away wealth is not enough as - 1. Giving up of responsibility to give efforts → as only donation isn't enough. 2. No duty towards ensuring outcomes as channelization of money important 3. Lack of local capacity ⇒ no NGOs are primary reason behind lack of outcome from CSR. 4. Lack of transparency → auditing issues. 5. Corruption among civil society ⇒ money doesnt reach intended beneficiary.

Way forward 1. Uphold Aurelius stoicism → be the agent of change. 2. Visit the poor - develop empathy 3. Work at grassroot ⇒ ensure outcomes ⊕ get satisfaction. 4. Work for Kant's duty dictum → actions speak louder than words.

This would uphold compassionate capitalism with focus on consequentialism.