What do you understand by judicial activism and overreach? Also discuss the associated concerns. (Answer in 200 words)
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
Judicial activism refers to judiciary going some further steps beside the set precedent to ensure that justice is delivered properly.
Judicial overreach is a case of Over-activism where judiciary encroaches in the areas of legislature or executive; either by itself legislating while delivering judgment or by directing executive to act in certain way.
Indian Judiciary have shown exceptional innovation in checking State excess and protecting human rights of individual but this activism many a times leads to overreach on parts of Judiciary.
Concerns associated with overreach - Violation of Principle of separation of power - Our constitution is built on balance between the three organs - Overreach by Judiciary is thus violation of principle - No Accountability - Since leaders are elected by people are accountable to them. - Judiciary on other hand is not accountable to people - Breach of People's mandate - Judiciary performing duties of other organs is a fraud on constitutional process. - Biased Judges - Judges being humans are often accused of bias towards an ideology.
Way forward - Judicial Restraint - Time and again Supreme Court highlighted the need for judiciary to show restraint. - Using Judicial activism as a rare tool in exceptional cases.
An activist Judiciary is not good for Judiciary itself as it leads to appointment of commited Judges. Restraint is the need of hour with activism as an exception.