Topper Copies

Governor is neither a saboteur nor a sage; he is a constitutional functionary who needs to be solely loyal to the Constitution. Critically examine the statement in the light of recent events.

Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025

As per Article 153, every state shall have a Governor who is executive head of state. His/her position is intensely debated as agent of union Government or head of state.

Governor is not a saboteur 1. Appointment of State Govt - Eg. Chief Minister and Council of Minister 2. Other functionaries like Advocate General, State Election Commissioners appointed 3. Exercises executive power - like seeking information from CM, directing minister to take up certain matters. 4. Ensure smooth constitutional machinery - Eg. imposition of Constitutional Emergency (Article 356) 5. Special responsibility in Schedule V and VI Areas 6. Chancellor of state universities.

Governor is not a sage 1. Holding State Legislature Bills - Eg. NEET Bill of Tamil Nadu 2. Delays in appointment of Vice Chancellor of State University 3. Refusing to call session of state Legislature - Eg. West Bengal 2022 4. Conflict between CM and Governor Eg. Tamil Nadu - over Motion of Thanks 5. Doctrine of Pleasure - Revoked by Kerala Governor against minister without CM's advice.

Governor as Constitutional Functionary 1. Should act as bridge between Union and state Government - promote Federal balance. 2. Appointment - Recommendation of Sarkaria and Punchhi Commission -> Apolitical individual belonging out of state -> away from active politics 3. Uphold Constitutional Morality - follow advice of council of ministers - follow constitutional provisions in legislation Eg. refrain from pocket veto, or delayed reserving bills for President. 4. Limited exercise of situational and Constitutional discretions

Governor provides stability to politics of a state and ensures federalism with tilt toward union government, but should uphold cooperation with state government