Strengthening the subordinate judiciary is vital for revitalizing the entire edifice of the Indian judicial system. Discuss. Also, examine the role of 'All India Judicial Services' (AIJS) in enhancing the effectiveness and efficiency of the Indian judiciary.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
The subordinate judiciary of India caters to maximum cases of Indian masses inclusive of civil cases - property, family disputes and criminal cases.
Need for strengthening Subordinate judiciary 1. Reduce judicial pendency - Presently 2-3 crore cases pending, >50% land disputes 2. Appeal process - poor jurisprudence leads large number of appeals increasing pendency on higher courts (6.4 lakh - High Court, 89000 - Supreme court) 3. High vacancy - leads to high caseburden per judge, poor quality of judgement due to less time 4. Lack of adequate judicial infrastructure and digitisation affects judicial functioning
Role of AIJS for Judicial Efficiency | Merit | Challenges | |---|---| | 1. Decrease judicial vacancy | 1. Federal Imbalance - appointment rights of state and high court | | 2. Seek meritorious candidates from entire India | 2. Issue of hearings in regional language | | 3. Judicial uniformity in subordinate court | 3. Impact promotions of judges already in subordinate courts | | 4. Multiplier effect in case of judicial pendency and appeals | 4. Aggravate inequality - selections of [?] sections |
AIJS was introduced in 42nd Constitutional Amendment to streamline judicial appointments and improve judicial process. However, it should be complemented by structural reforms like reducing disposal time of cases and rise in case clearance rate