The 44th Amendment Act of 1978 served as a remedy to the draconian measures undertaken through the 42nd Amendment Act of 1976 during the 'Emergency'. Critically examine.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
The 42nd Amendment Act of 1976 brought multiple changes in the Indian Constitution, making it a 'mini constitution' in itself.
Draconian Measures in 42nd Amendment 1. The laws to give effect to Directive principles of state policy not bound by Article 14, 19, 31 of Fundamental Rights 2. Reduce power of Judicial Review through Article 32A and Article 226A. 3. Extended terms of Parliament from 5 year to 6 years 4. Removed need of quorum for Parliamentary process.
44th Amendment as Antidote to 42nd Amendment (i) Changes to process of emergency 1. only for 'armed rebellion' and external threat, not internal rebellion. 2. Reduced period of approval from Parliament to 1 month for national Emergency. 3. Resolution to revoke emergency in Lok Sabha to president -> 10% of Lok sabha members 4. Limits on Constitutional Emergency under Article 356 - Consensus of Election Commission to extend beyond 1 year
(ii) Deleted 'Right to Property' as fundamental right - retained as Constitutional Right (Article 300A) (iii) Restored power of judicial review
Some provisions of 42nd Amendment like Tribunals, Fundamental Duties etc. were retained 44th Amendment sought to make constitution free from arbitrary measures of executive.