Recent controversies over alleged malpractices in the electoral rolls have renewed demands for the mandatory linkage of Aadhaar with Voter ID. What is your opinion? Give reasons in support of your answer.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
The case of additional voters in Maharashtra elections and allegation by west bengal of duplicate voters has renewed debate of Aadhar link to voter Id.
Necessity to link Aadhar & voter ID - Ease of registration - reduce complicated procedure of voter Id registration. - Reduce duplicate voters - Multiple voting seen in rural & urban areas. - Faster validation During election with 'biometric' authentication - uphold ideals of 'One Person One vote' - reduce scenes of electoral malpractices, ghost voters and identity theft
Concerns with linking Aadhar-voter Id - Against Aadhar Case judgement - can be used only welfare schemes, can not be mandatory for other purpose. - Disenfranchisment violate Article-326 of constitution. Lack of 'Aadhar' registration not mandatory - Cyber security issues 1. Aadhar Data leaks in 2019, 2024 (Telegram) affect data security of voters 2. Electoral Data Manipulations by foreign state & non-state actors (Eg Russia interfered in Ukraine elections) - Aadhar based on residence Not a document of citizenship. Provide franchise to illegal migrants & refugees.
Way forward - Election Commission of India 1. Update electoral rolls based on present demography 2. Coordinate with Census operation 2027 - Pilot Project Aadhar-voter Id link based on some centres at voluntary basis (Metros). Evaluate results for expansion - Consultations with public & opposition for harmonious implementation - Data Protection Strengthen DPDP 2022 law to ensure data privacy & security
Elections are identity of sole presence of democracy and electoral rolls ensure their sanctity. ECI should take initiatives to strengthen India as 'liberal democracy' over electoral autocracy (V-Dem Institute).