Is the growing demand for stricter regulation of online content justified, or does it pose a threat to the right to freedom of speech and expression? Examine in light of recent judicial pronouncements.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
The 'India Got Latent' row about poor regulation of online content and debate of free speech has brought the issue in limelight again.
Demand of stricter Regulation of online Content - Address Obscenity - unregulated content proliferation of illicit and vulgar commentary (Eg) use of deepfakes for celebrity porn imagery - Radicalisation Below threshold commentary for radical groups / terror organisation to spread agenda (Eg) Hate speech / radical agenda by TRF - Fake news Invalidated and unverified news spread without any penal action (Eg) Fakenews during Operation Sindoor - Echo chambers Algorithmic bias to propagate and reinforce certain news/information - Cyberbullying & Abuse - use of social media to denigrade or abuse (leading cause of depression in adolescents) - Invasion of privacy violates A-21 (Eg) forced filming by social media influencers
Against freedom of Speech & Expression - Violation of Article 19(1)(a) Kunal Kamra Case opposed Fact Check unit by govt for 'chilling effect on critical assessment' - Misuse of Laws - like sedition, UAPA. criticism of govt equated to criticism of Nation (Vinod Dua Case) - Difficult to regulate accepted in Facebook vs Union of India case by SC due to distributed nature and prevalence of false positives & - Paternalistic State - regulation will enhance State's presence in individual's life creating totalitarianisms (Eg) excessive delegated legislation under IT Rules, 2021 - Technological limitations - Encryption breaking (Eg) whatsapp end to end encryption - break hurts privacy
with Supreme Court upholding Article 19 horizontally (Kaushal Kishore case), a graded regulation on online content is necessary, so it safeguards public rights & social-constitutional morality