Assess the role of NITI Aayog over the past decade in promoting cooperative and competitive federalism.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
Niti Aayog celebrates 10 years of its genesis in 2025, with establishment in 2015 as think tank of government & replaced Planning Commission.
Role of Niti Aayog in federalism Competitive - Releases indices to rank state performance (Eg) Composite water Index, Export Competitiveness Index - Reports on state's performance on particular schemes (Eg) Case studies of Jal Jeevan mission
Cooperative Federalism 1. Policy inputs for collaboration of centre and state 2. Evaluation of centrally sponsored schemes 3. Chief minister's subgroup for state's perspective on government policies 4. Governing Council - including states in planning (opposed to planning commission) and regional councils
Limitation of Niti Aayog in Federalism - Non-binding suggestions Lacks enforceability of suggestion (in Planning Commission), considered ineffective by states - Lack of financial powers - reduced contribution in quelling stressed fiscal federalism - Spillover of stressed centre-state ties - opposition states like Tamil Nadu & Kerala do not participate effectively - Data & reports criticised as biased towards centre & glorifying their stance - Under-delivered promises creation of vision document with cooperative federalism undercelised (long term planning overlooked)
Way forward - Niti Aayog given binding powers for protecting state's interests - Political neutral mobilisation enhanced cooperation of states through regular meetings, discussions for reforms & pilot projects - Transparent Methodology for indices & comparisons.
Niti Aayog came with promise of revolutionising planning, it needs to be empowered to act as 'Transformative Engine of growth'