Topper Copies

What circumstances led to the formation of the National Green Tribunal? Evaluate if it has met its stated objectives in more than a decade of its existence.

Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025

National Green Tribunal is statutory tribunal created under NGT Act, 2010 to adjudicate on environmental issues related to selected acts.

Circumstances for introduction of NGT, 2010 1. Rise in environmental jurisprudence eg. MC Mehta cases 2. Increase in climate change consciousness - UNFCCC conventions, Kyoto Protocol 3. Environment Based Directive Policies of State Policy - Article 48A 4. International obligation on India

Effectiveness of NGT 1. Strengthen Environmental jurisprudence - eg. disposal of Bhopal Gas Tragedy waste 2. Input of experts - presence of judicial and administrative experts in panel 3. Binding industries and state to environment commitments - Public Trust Doctrine 4. Safeguard environment - eg. action on unlawful deforestation in Delhi 5. Presence of regional benches - Decentralised jurisprudence.

Limitation of NGT 1. High case pendency - hurts steady case disposal 2. Vacancy in NGT -> for experts; -> lack of adequate secretarial assistance 3. Regional Benches - should be near environmentally vulnerable areas - Eg. Himalayas, western Ghat. 4. Appeals to Supreme Court - dilutes purpose of NGT - reduce pendency and increase expertise of NGT 5. No jurisdiction on Forest Rights Act - important for environment conservation

NGT was an advancement of India [?] an environmentally responsible state. It should be strengthened with filling up vacancy, supportive staff and widened jurisdiction for environmental justice.