Throwing light on the constitutional provisions for safeguarding the autonomy of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG,) recommend measures to enhance its role as the conscience keeper of the government.
Chakka Snehith, AIR 139, 2025
Article 148 provides for the establishment of the office of CAG.
Dr. BR Ambedkar - called office of CAG as the most important office under the constitution.
Provisons safeguarding autonomy of CAG
1. Appointment - CAG can be appointed only in the manner prescribed in the constitution 2. Terms of office and salary cannot be degraded post appointment 3. Fixed tenure - 6 year tenure and maximum age of 65 years 4. Expenditure of the office of CAG and salaries of CAG and members working under her are charged on the Constitution or Consolidated fund of India 5. Removal - can be removed by a motion passed by both houses with a special majority
Recommendations to enhance CAG Role
1. Former CAG Vinod Rai recommendations - a) Bring PPP projects under CAG ambit - b) Mandatory discussion on the reports submitted by CAG to the parliament. 2. Committee to recommend names for appointment as CAG to president - include PM, leader of opposition and minister 3. CAG need to take into consideration of implementation challenges while doing the proprietary audit 4. Enhancing expertise of officers under CAG to detect creative accounting. 5. For security expenditure - there can be a provision for secrete audit by high level Committee
Financial accountability is crucial in overall accountability of executive to the legislature. CAG reforms can enhance the control of parliament over the executive