Topper Copies

Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the first-past-the-post (FPTP) system in ensuring a representative polity. Can a move towards a proportional electoral system address the limitations of the first-past-the-post system?

Chakka Snehith, AIR 139, 2025

Indian democracy employs the FPTP system for elections in legislative assembly, Lok Sabha.

Strengths of FPTP

1. Familiarity of the system - from historical perspective. This allowed continuation of FPTP after independence 2. Easy system compared to other systems like proportional representation 3. Fixed representative for each constituency can be possible 4. Definitive verdict can be reached post election and reduce the hung assemblies or parliaments

Despite the strengths of FPTP there are some weakness of the system.

Weakness

1. Winner of a constituency may not get majority of the votes i.e 50% +1 2. loss of the votes - In recent Andhra Pradesh election, despite getting ~35% of vote share a party got only 11 seats in assembly. 3. Not representing voters will accurately as FPTP winner may get 50% Vote share

Due to these weakness, many are calling for move towards proportional representation (PR) system

However PR system may not suit Indian context because:

1. No representative to a particular constituency 2. Can lead to vote bank politics as many parties can target and divide India based on religion, region etc 3. Impose majoritarianism and may lead to less representation of minority 4. Unstability of the government due to lack of clear mandate Ex Frequent elections in Israel

Recommendations

1. law Commission - Hybrid model suggested where 25% seats can be added to parliament and assembly that can be filled by PR system 2. Testing on pilot basis and increase voter awareness

Indian multicultural society needs representation and FPTP is good for the purpose. But PR system can be adopted on a wider consensus as law commission recommended.