The ordinance-making power of the executive is antithetical to the principles of accountability and democratic consensus. Examine with suitable illustrations.
Chakka Snehith, AIR 139, 2025
Article 123 and 213 of the constitution provides for ordinance making power for central and state executive respectively.
Antithetical to principles of accountability
1. No legislative scrutiny of the bill so the accountability to of the legislature will be diluted - Ex Committee for air quality management in NCT Bill - via ordinance but later withdrawn in parliament. 2. Ordinances can go against democratic will of the people - (Ex) Farm Bills bought as ordinances and then got passed but ultimately repealed due to opposition from certain sections of farmers. 3. No check or examination by parliamentary standing committees that refine any bill to shape it along peoples aspirations 4. No public comments will be called in case of ordinances - This will undermine the democratic consensus.
The government must abide by the judicial directions given in Krishna kumar case, DC Wadhwa case and RC Cooper case to ensure that power is not misused.