Topper Copies

Why is it important to ensure separation of powers between various organs of the State? Also, explain Indian model of separation of power with relevant provisions in the constitution.

Chakka Snehith, AIR 139, 2025

Seperation of power is a concept given by lord Montesquie. In this each organ of the state performs designated roles and donot interfere in other organs' function

Importance of seperation of powers

1. Reduces conflict among different organs and smooth functioning of state 2. Seperation of power principle is in line with the idea of constitutionalism 3. Diversity of opinion and people in the state which will enrich governance 4. Gives scope for checks and Balances on each organ of the state 5. Prevents concentration of power on one organ and hence act as protecting agent to democracy

Indian model

Indian model is not a strict seperation of power (USA model), but our model is based on checks and balances, cooperation and accountability

There is no strict seperation between legislature and executive as legislature is responsible to executive (Article 75, 164) and to be part of executive one has to be part of legislature (double membership)

Also parliament is not completely sovereign due to judicial pronouncements such as Basic structure (Keshavananda Bharati case)

Some other constitutional provision

- Article 50 - envisages seperation between executive & Judiciary - Article 121, 211 - judicial conduct cannot be discussed in legislature - Article 122, 212 - parliamentary proceedings cannot be called into court

Indian constitutional makers gave preference to checks and balances and cooperation among organs so as to suit Indian diversity and parliamentary system.