Considering the non-enforceable nature of fundamental duties and directive principles of state policy, critically examine their impact in socio-political norms.
Chakka Snehith, AIR 139, 2025
Part-IV and IVA of the constitution deal with fundamental duties (IVA) and Directive principles of state policy (DPSP - IV) are non justiciable where as part-III fundamental duties are enforcable.
Reasons for non-enforcement
1. States freedom to decide when to implement DPSP due to financial constraints 2. Smooth functioning of states as enforcing DPSP will increase pressure on government 3. Fundamental duties - are enforable to an extent by various other laws - (Ex) Prevention of insults to national symbols
However due to their non-enforcability there are many socio-political issues
Negative impact on socio-political norms
1. Persistence of social problems - (Ex) lack of equal wage to women - Communalism - persistent due to lack of unity and uniform Civil code (Article 44) 2. Concentration of wealth - goes against equal distribution of wealth (Article 39) - Oxfam report - 1% Indians hold 66% wealth 3. Reducing role of cottage industries due to rise in factory products 4. Environmental pollution and climate change going against DPSP to protect nature 5. lack of Scientific Temper against Article 51A due to orthodoxy and superstitions
Enforcing DPSP and Fundamental duties can bring many changes
1. DPSP will bring socio-economic democracy along with political democracy (Fundamental rights) 2. DPSP will become common manifesto for all political parties 3. Fundamental duties can enforce discipline and a sense of unity among Indians
Considering the non-viable nature of finances, DPSP can be implement at right time. But they must be prioritized by all parties irrespective of their agenda & ideology.