Topper Copies

What do you mean by 'doctrine of essentiality'? How has judiciary used this doctrine to address conflict between various fundamental rights? Explain with examples.

Chakka Snehith, AIR 139, 2025

Doctrine of essentiality was given by supreme court to decide on 'essential practices' of a religion

Evolved in - Shirur Matt case

This doctrine had helped Supreme court to decide about essential practices of religion and limit practices that infringe fundamental rights.

1. Banning Diwali crackers - Court ruled that burning crackers is not essential practice and thus can be banned inorder to protect right to clean air (Article 21) 2. Triple Talaq judgement - Supreme court in Shayara Bano case gave primacy to women rights over religious laws. 3. Banning Hijab in schools in Karnataka - Court ruled that Hijab is not an essential practice under Islam and thus can be regulated by law. 4. Sabarimala Verdict - India Young lawyers association Vs State of Kerala, court had given women right to enter temple.

However there had been overreach in some cases such as, court declaring Sallekhana not essential practice under Jainism

Judiciary must use this doctrine sparingly and to protect fundamental rights but must not lead to Judicial Papism