Anti-defection law has failed to address and resolve the evil of political defection satisfactorily. Discuss various issues surrounding the Anti-defection law and recommend some corrective measures.
Chakka Snehith, AIR 139, 2025
52nd constitutional amendment act had intoduced Xth schedule [?] which contains anti defection law.
In recent times there had been many innovative ways of switching sides by means of mass resignations to avoid anti-defection law.
Issues present
1. Politicisation of office of speaker as she has to make decisions and no time limit was prescribed 2. limiting freedom of speech of legislators as they cannot vote as per conscience. 3. Donot deal with mass resignations of members to join another party. 4. Empowering whip largely to deal with members.
Soli Sorabjee had famously called the law as "Remedy as worse than malady".
Corrective measures needed
1. Time limit for decision making - Supreme court gave 3 months time limit in Meghachandra Singh case for speaker to make decision 2. ECI recommendation - a) Prepoll alliances need to be considered as party - b) Governor can decide on defections based on ECI recommendation 3. Limiting use of whip only for important ones like no-confidence, money bill etc
Political parties must limit issuing whips unnecessarily and need to respect freedom of legislators rather than imposing party views.