How far have Forest Rights Act, 2006 and PESA Act, 1996 been successful in attaining their desired objectives? What needs to be done to improve their implementation on ground?
Chakka Snehith, AIR 139, 2025
PESA Act, 1996 expands the part IX of constitution to scheduled areas, whereas Forest Rights Act (FRA) 2006 gives numerous rights to tribals and other traditional forest dwellers
Successes of PESA, 1996
1. Effective functioning of panchayats in tribal areas overcoming traditional structures 2. Representation of STs in decision making at upper district level 3. Empoweling Grama Sabha to govern and develop tribal villages 4. Paved way for women empowerment
Success of FRA, 2006
1. Expanded rights of Tribals in forest - Title rights - management rights - Development rights - Community rights
under FRA, 2006. 2. Reduce illegal eviction of tribals from their lands (Ex) Dongriya Kondh of Niyamgiri fought against Vedanta mining. 3. Ownership of tribals over minor forest produce (MFP) 4. Tribals involvement in forest management 5. Protecting ecosystem (Ex) Critical Tiger Habitat under FRA, 2006.
Despite these success there are limitations due to - Bureaucracy not loosening power, limited implementation on ground, lack of awareness of people, Bureaucratisation of development and process and lack of political will in states
Measures to improve implementation
1. Sensitisation of bureaucracy on tribal culture and educate them on the acts so that they can implement them with conviction. 2. Gadchiroli case study - successful implementation of FRA as community asserted their rights - This can happen with increasing awareness of tribals 3. States need to come up with rules to implement these acts (Ex) Around 7 states have comeup with rules of FRA, 2006 till now 4. Preventing misuse of provisions - (Ex) Coal bearing areas act being used to evict tribals from forests.
Both FRA, 2006 and PESA, 1996 need to be implemented with letter & spirit to achieve sustainable development of tribals.