Topper Copies

Elucidate the differences between Western and Indian model of secularism. To what extent do you agree with the criticism that Indian model of secularism is susceptible to promoting minority appeasement?

Gaurav Chopra, AIR 83, 2025

Secularism refers to seperation of state and religion matters.

| Western Model | Indian Model | |---|---| | -> no involvement of state and religion in each other domains. | -> allows involvement of state in religious matters but not vice-versa | | -> Complete Distance [sketch: State and Religion boxes with a crossed double-headed arrow between them] | -> Principled Distance [sketch: State and Religion boxes joined through an oval, arrow from State towards Religion] | | -> Anti-religion or no public display of religious symbol. Eg: France. | -> Is not anti-religion and freedom to display religious symbol subject to public health and morality | | -> Focus on inter-religious denominations only. | -> Both inter-religion (between different religion) and intra-religion (within same religion) |

Indian Secularism -> Minority Appeasement

1. Fundamental Right 28 and 29 -> rights of Minorities only. 2. Overturning of Supreme court judgements. Eg: Shah Bano Judgement for Right to Maintenance of Muslim women. 3. Article 44: requires Uniform Civil code but not yet legislated.

Indian secularism -> does not promote minority appeasement

1. Right of all religion -> to maintain their charitable institutions (Article 25 & 26). 2. Various Supreme court judgement and doctrines Eg: Essential Religious Practices judgement and Triple Talaq judgement. 3. Involvement of participatory and stakeholder consensus for bringing UCC.

Thus, Indian secularism does not promote minority appeasement.