Topper Copies

"The end cannot justify the means, for the simple and obvious reason that the means employed determine the nature of the ends produced." Discuss with suitable examples.

Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025

Moral discourse of Kant and Gandhiji over Machiavelli and Lokayata ethics places centricity on means over ends.

Determination of ends by means 1. Means are an integral part of ends - eg) achieving happiness of family & society well through charity. 2. Means are but an action, an end in themselves - all action must be teleologically correct 3. Categorical imperative or universalism of values and virtues like justice, fairness must be maintained in ends and means (Kant) 4. Inviolability of human dignity central to all action. Ends do not justify violation of these. - eg) National interest furtherance via 'just wars' is criticised. 5. End of greed, profiteering and utilitarian egoism is not justifying of any means employed - eg) Capitalist overtures over environment.

However, ends can also be means-justified: - Heinz dilemma of saving wife over ethics of stealing - Good ends might require illicit means, eg) waging encounter against terror attack - means are but mere tools, eg) substantive justice over procedural

Thus, ends and means must be a balanced whole in their ethicality and soundness.