Topper Copies

Why was parliamentary form of government adopted for independent India? Do you agree with the opinion that Indian government is increasingly transitioning towards presidential form? Justify.

Gaurav Chopra, AIR 83, 2025

Parliamentary form of Government refers to the selection of executives from the Parliament of a country.

It is responsible form of Govt. as the executive is responsible to parliament, in general & to Lok Sabha, in particular.

Lok Sabha, can remove the Govt from power by simply passing a No-Confidence Motion.

India Selected this form of Govt: - Familiarity with the system, as it was followed during the British Rule in India. - Constituent Assembly's preference of Responsible form of Govt over the Stable form of Govt (∵ Presidential System of Govt). - Parliamentary Govt has less conflict & require more coordination among the arms of govt than Presidential form of govt. - Checks & Balances system of Parliamentary govt was preferred over strict seperation of power of Presidential Govt.

There is increasing opinion that Indian Govt is transitioning towards the Presidential form because: - Just as President is the supreme power is USA, Prime Minister is the pivot around which the govt works. - The President (US) is Free from the control of Legislature (congress), there is also that the executive in India is free, in real terms, from the control of Parliament due to its super majority. - In USA, Supreme Court is seperated from the control of the other arms. Just as, in India, the SC is more powerful and independent from other arms.

However, this opinion is not correct: - In US, the president is free to appoint anyone he wants as his minister. Whereas, in India, the PM has to select he's ministers from the MPs. - There are sufficient checks & balances in the Constitution & Parliament to prevent executive from being the supreme power

Thus the Parliamentary form of Govt that is being practiced in India is distinct from the presidential form of govt.