Topper Copies

Why is it important to ensure separation of powers between various organs of the State? Also, explain Indian model of separation of power with relevant provisions in the constitution.

Gaurav Chopra, AIR 83, 2025

Seperation of Power, propounded by Montesquie, distributes & divides the power of State into 3 arms.

Importance of Seperation of Power - Prevents despotism of state. - Division of power → specialisation & Special focus on each aspect of governance. - Reduces concentration of power in one arm of state. - Brings the needs for coordination & Control between various arms.

How Seperation of Power is practiced in India - Legislature cannot discuss the conduct of judges of Supreme & High court. - Judiciary cannot inquire into proceedings of legislature. - Executive cannot remove judges of Supreme & high court.

However, this seperation of power is not strictly followed in India, as it is done in USA. Rather, a system of Checks & Balances has been established.

Checks & Balances

Judiciary - Executive: Judiciary can command executive to do certain tasks to ensure complete justice Under Article 142. - Legislature: Judiciary can review the validity of acts of parliament Under Article 13.

Legislature - Judiciary: Can remove the judges through special resolution & procedure mentioned in constitution. - Executive: Maintain control over it through No confidence motion, vote of thanks, etc.

Executive - Legislature: executive can make laws through ordinance power. - Judiciary: judges appointed by President on the recommendation of executive.

Indian Constitution has modified the doctrine of seperation of power to suit its needs & situations uniquely.