The doctrine of separation of power in the Indian political system is 'not water-tight' but rather based on the principle of 'checks and balances'. Elaborate.
Gaurav Chopra, AIR 83, 2025
The Doctrine of Seperation of Power(S.O.P) was originally given by Montesquiee. It Means the division of executive, legislative & judicial powers between three arms.
In India, S.O.P is not water tight, but based on 'Checks & Balances'.
[a diagram of three overlapping circles, Executive (Implement Laws), Legislature (Make Laws) and Judiciary (adjudicates on law), with a box "Checks & Balances." pointing to the shaded overlap]
Need for S.O.P - Limit Arbitrary excess of each other. - Provide specialisation for each service - Maintain & autonomy of each arm. - Ensure protection of fundamental Rights.
Indian S.O.P ~ Not Water-Tight.
1. Legislature - Acts as Judiciary: deciding privileges, impeachment of President, judges. - Act as Executive: deciding on fund allocation under MPLADS.
2. Judiciary - Act as Executive: when control over subordinate courts. - Act as Legislative: Has power to make own Rules (Article 141).
3. Executive - Act as Legislature: Passing Ordinances, delegated legislations. - Act as Judiciary: formation of Tribunals, etc.
Indian S.O.P ~ Checks & Balances
1. Legislature over Executive & Judiciary - Removal of Judges; No-confidence motion - Parliamentary tools over executive. - Passes law that determine jurisdiction of executive & judiciary.
2. Executive over Judiciary & Legislature - Appointment of Judges in Courts. - Power of Whip in legislature - Power to summon, prorogue & dissolution.
3. Judiciary over Executive & legislature - Article 142: Complete Justice - Article 13: determines validity of Act. - Power of Judicial Review, Basic structure.
In I.R. Coehlo Case, Supreme Court has designated the system of "SOP as essential for maintaining constitutionalism in India."