Differentiate between the clemency powers of the Presidents of India and the USA. Also, critically examine the vesting of clemency power in the executive.
Gaurav Chopra, AIR 83, 2025
Clemency powers or Pardoning Powers means ability of executive to lift the punishment as well as the Conviction on the grounds of empathy or 'corrective' justice.
| Indian President | President of USA | |---|---| | 1. Pardoning power relate to Union Laws and Death Penalty. | 1. Pardoning Power related to only Federal crime. | | 2. On the advise of Council of ministers | 2. President himself empowered. | | 3. Judicial review on the grounds of being 'malafide' | 3. No Judicial review. Eg Joe Biden pardoned his son Hunter Biden. | | 4. Broader power - Can lift Death penalty of State Law. | 4. Narrower- only related to Federal Crimes. | | 5. Procedure set by Council of ministers and Judiciary. | 5. No set procedure- on Presidential will |
However, both of them have the power of pardon, reprieve, respite and clemency.
Reasons behind Vesting of Clemency power 1. To enforce 'corrective' or reformational justice. 2. To correct the mistakes of judiciary as the law is rigid and blind. 3. To show empathy and compassion as a State virtue. 4. Historical basis → UK King has clemency power, 'fountain of Justice' during Mughals. 5. Human centric approach in governance.
Arguments against vesting of clemency power 1. Violates separation of power → executive encroaching on judicial space. 2. Executive Malafide → may use it for vested interest. 3. Clemency petition cause delays in judgements. 4. Use for political purpose. Eg Afzal Guru Case.
Thus, any exercise of clemency power must be backed by transparency and accountability to uphold 'spirit' of justice.