Topper Copies

Despite constitutional backing to the institutions of local governance, the idea of decentralisation has remained hostage to several structural bottlenecks. Elucidate.

Gaurav Chopra, AIR 83, 2025

72nd & 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act gave constitutional backing to Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRI) and Urban local bodies (ULB).

Features of 73rd & 74th Amendment

Structural Bottlenecks to Decentralisation

I. Funds 1. Tied nature of Funds → Central Sector schemes, etc. 2. Lack of decentralised financing. 3. State Finance Commission not constituted by many states. 4. PRI & ULB not taxing → due to political needs.

II. Functions 1. Devolution of functions not compulsory. Eg Karnataka devolved 26 function, some States devolved 3. 2. Duplication of Institutions Eg Haryana's Rural Development Agency has functions similar to PRI.

III. Functionaries 1. Dependence on State govt. 2. No self-cadre, or permanent employees. 3. Control of District Administrator. 4. Sarpanch Pati.

IV. Functionality 1. Corruption & nexus between Sarpanch & legislature. 2. Nepotism in awarding contracts. 3. Lack of effective social audit mechanism

Way Forward

I. Funds - Compulsory forming State finance Commission. - Capacity building to raise funds. Eg Through Urban Bonds.

II. Functions - Amendment to make devolution mandatory. - Removal of duplicate parastatals.

III. functionaries - Cadre based management. Eg Karnataka. - Education & Awareness → capacity building of functionaries.

IV. functionality - Improve infrastructure, effective use of ICT to monitor schemes. - Institutionalise Social Audit.

Through effective decentralisation, Gandhiji's dream of Swarajya would be accomplished.