"The inability of the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) to address critical conflicts and maintain international peace and security underscores the urgent need for reforms." Examine the statement and present a case for India's permanent membership in the UNSC.
Devyanshi Kaura, AIR 71, 2025
2022 and 2023 witnessed the onset of the Ukraine-Russia and Israel-Palestine armed conflict respectively. The UNSC in its present state appears to be a paper tiger in combating these.
Case for India's permanent Membership at the UNSC 1. Changed global realities since 1945 - India has became a nuclear armed state, and world's third largest economy (PPP) 2. Imbalances in global security architecture: - Global south has no representation in the UNSC's permanent seats despite having large population, GDP and outnumbering North countries - Global south also faces disproportionate burden of emerging threats like insurgency, poverty, climate change, and digital insecurity 3. Improving effectiveness of the UNSC : - current deadlocks due to squabbles between the P5 members - voices of other regions and members like G4 (Germany, India, Japan, Brazil) - will help to break these 4. India's leadership of global south - through NAM, then G77, G33, Voice of the Global South - significant goodwill enjoyed in Latin America, Africa and Asia - positions us to be a prominent representative through a seat at the high table
Hence, the time for UNSC reform has come. Any hope for achieving and sustaining global peace hinges on making the UN a truly representative and consensus driven body.