Bring out the differences between 'coming together federations' and 'holding together federations' with examples. (Answer in 200 words)
Pakshal Secretry, AIR 8, 2025
Article 1 of constitution defines India to be an "Union of States" There are generally two types of federations (i) coming together federation ; (ii) holding together federation.
(A) 'Coming together federation' - In this types of federation many State come together to form an union. - The States exist as a free independent entity and have an identity of their own. - States have right to succede from the Union. Thus, also called 'destructible Union of indestructible States' - Generally, State and the union have equal power with the balance more in favour of States. - Features like different constitution multiple citizenship etc are visible.
(B) 'Holding together federation' - A union divides itself into various small states - States have no individual identity of their own - States have no right to succede from union - Power is shifted towards the Union, and union can override state decision in many cases - Single citizenship, Unified Judiciary, single constitution are some of peculiar features.
United State of America, where 50 States came together to form an union can be termed as an example of 'coming together federation' In USA, states have their different constitution, different Supreme Court for each state and residual power with States making it an perfect example of federation
While India and Canada, where the union got divided into various state is example of 'holding together federation'. In India, we have a unified Judiciary, single Constitution and a powerful Union.
Successionist tendencies, historical context and divisive forces required India to be a 'holding together federation' with a powerful Union.