Topper Copies

Dual control of All India Services often becomes a cause for federal tensions. Explain the rationale behind adopting such a system. Also, evaluate the changes proposed by the central government in March 2022 in the IAS (Cadre) Rules, 1954.

Harshita Goyal, AIR 2, 2024

Article 312 of India Constitution provides for All India services who are recruited and alloted to states by Centre but posted and assigned their roles by States.

Rationale behind dual control of AIS 1. To promote unity and integrity of India, so that states can't function as separate system. 2. To uphold Article 256 of Constitution of India: i.e to ensure states function as per Centre's Instruction. 3. For implementing Central schemes in states as per specific states' needs. 4. To provide standardization and flexibility in services.

Recent changes made in AIS Cadre Rules, 1954 has been criticized by states.

Changes made to 1954 Rules 1. If states fail to implement deputation orders in time, Centre can call officers as stipulated by them. 2. officers list to prepared in consultation with States, however if disagreement, Centre's will to prevail. 3. If services of AIS officers needed by Centre in 'public interest' can call officers any time.

Rationale proposed by Dopt To solve the problem of inadequate officers in Central ministries. However, is criticized by states as - a) against cooperative federalism. - b) May lower down the morale of officers by creating insecurity in minds. - c) Create unnecessary and avoidable legal and administrative issues. - d) May lower the control of State's political executive over bureaucracy. - e) Use of Bureaucracy for fulfilling Centre's political agenda.

Since All India Services are steel frame of the country, any rule impacting their independence, morale and effectiveness should be taken after wider consultation and in Consensus building approach.