An archaic and obsolete edifice of civil services does not augur well for a welfare state. Examine the various issues surrounding the civil services in the country. What suggestions would you make for their reform?
Harshita Goyal, AIR 2, 2024
Civil Services includes that group selected in government on the basis of merit and survives various government (elected) transitions, thus known as 'Permanent executive' organ of Government.
Advantages of having Civil Servants 1. Serves thought the country, acts as binding factor. 2. formulates policies and implements them, acting as bridge between people and political executive. 3. Allows continuity in policies with required adaptation. 4. Brings rationality into populist policies of political executive.
However suffering from major issues : - a) Lack of professionalism and inadequate capacity building. eg Red Tapism and delay - b) Faulty reward structure, benefits corrupts and penalizes honest (Frequent transfers) - c) Inadequate transparency and accountability eg: No protection to whistleblowers. - d) Political interference and administrative aquiescense. - e) Goal Displacement - Goal fixation (Personal Goals v. National Goals) - Ends-Means Reversal (Rules > Objectives) - eg F.IR rejected to file to show reduced crime rate. - f) Personal Power gains over Positional power. (more subjective) (objective)
Therefore needs urgent reforms to bring transparency, accountability, responsiveness, professionalism and democratic character of civil services
Civil Services Reforms needed 1. Reform in Selection process, focusing equally on morals and values and calibre and aptitude 2. Training reforms. to make them innovative while working in a framework of rules. 3. e-governance, RTI for more transparency and accountability. 4. Move towards Professional Bureaucracy - Rules -> to curb subjectivity - Professionalism -> to bring efficiency and speed. - through bringing Competition and Restructuring - eg Recognition of Role of NGOs; eg Use of IT 5. Amendment of Prevention of corruption Act to act as deterrent.
As N. Vittal (ex CVC) stated, we should move from 'fat to FAT bureaucracy'. Mission Karamyogi, 360 Performance appraisal and compulsory retirement after 15 years of corrupt officers - steps in right direction.