Discuss how the Indian Constitution's approach to secularism differs from that of France. What can France learn from India?
Devyanshi Kaura, AIR 71, 2025
Controversies over ban on hijabs and bar on outward religious displays in France have sparked a debate on the nature of French secularism. In this context, it is worthwhile to compare Indian and French Secularism.
DIFFERENCE between Indian and French Secularism 1. Origin and evolution: - Indian secularism stemmed from experience under colonial rule - when diverse socio-cultural and religious groups' imbalanced development led to communalism - French secularism arose from Europe's history of domination of the church in political life, and hence the need to separate the state from the church 2. Philosophical underpinnings: - Indian secularism based on equal respect to and equal protection to all religions - Reflected in : 1. Article 25 - individual freedom in religious belief 2. Article 26 - group rights 3. Article 27, 28 - state's equidistance from religious activity 4. Article 29 and 30 - religious minority rights to safeguard culture - French secularism rooted in laicite - - no legal recognition to any religion - separation of politics and religion - religion as a private affair, and no public displays of religious beliefs or identity eg - ban on wearing of Hijabs
What French can learn from Indian Secularism 1. Accomodation of diversity of religious beliefs: - Post decolonisation, French has witnessed increasing population of non-Christian immigrant populations like Muslims - Need to accomodate to ensure social harmony 2. Expanding ambit of secularism to adapt to changing social realities Eg - perceived suppression of religiosity has made France target of Islamist attacks - French Muslim youth even more vulnerable 3. Shift from negative to positive laicite: - religion as a positive contribution to enriched public life and ethics Eg - Indian society's religiousity permeates through all aspect of life - concepts of dharma, karma find presence in law, politics, economics
Hence French secularism needs to adapt itself to changing times - and recognise increasingly fluid and plural character of modern societies.